By Shaima AlTamimi (@iamshaima)
It has been a while since I wanted to discuss a topic of paramount importance and as I write this, something tells me this piece maybe a hit or miss. Either way, I know it needs to be discussed.
A few months ago, I was sitting with friends and family members and someone was making fun of how their colleagues always give lousy excuses to skip work. Another relative of mine who recently graduated from the UK, told me about a research she conducted for a company in the UAE as part of her dissertation program. She shared the following facts with us from her findings.
In the year 2009, the total number of sick leave days taken from a company of approximately 5000 employees was around 18,000 days. The vast nature of this company entails having employees at the HQ and employees in the fields. You would think that field employees would incur more sick leave days due to hazardous work conditions and hot weather, but think again. 65% of total sick leaves were taken by office employees.
As common sense would also have it, the older you grow, the sicker you become right? Well in this case, 45% of sick leave taken was by employees under the age of 35. Employees over the age of 50 accounted for only 15% of total sick leave.
The real shocker now is in comprehending the fact that the UAE nationals make up almost 12,000 days of sick leave. Let us just assume that sick leave is the measure for well-being. Does this mean that Emiratis are sick and do not have access to proper healthcare? Surely not.
I find these statistics very disturbing, not only because they represent an obvious abuse of the corporate trust placed on employees, but mainly because many Emiratis ruin the reputation of their fellow colleagues who are hard working and sincere. The youth have been fighting this stereotypical phenomenon that Emiratis are lazy and do not work. I am not here to say this is true or false, but I am here to shed light on the fact that it does not apply to all Emiratis.
Contrary to popular belief, not all UAE nationals are born with a golden spoon in their mouth. Even if some are, many have the desire and determination to make a name for themselves just like anybody else.
Take Noura Al Kaabi from twofour54, a young lady who graduated from the UAE University and leads her company with all professionalism. There is Nayla Al Khaja, one of the leading Emirati directors who opened her own production company right after graduation. Let us not forget the Wildpeeta brothers who struggled to open their currently thriving Emirati Shawarma concept after 7 years of chasing for funding. How about Ali Al Saloom, who quit his government job to start his own cultural consultancy that now serves the biggest repeat private and government clients? Check out Saleh Al Braiki with his GCC wide initiative called “Think Up GCC” which is a platform for supporting Khaleejis start up businesses and talents. The list goes on with inspiring people that do more than just show up to work!
I fail to understand the high level of sick leave reports. Is it because Emiratis are not given enough responsibilities? Or, is it because they do not have the drive to carry out their responsibilities in a trustworthy manner? Perhaps some of them work for the sake of receiving a paycheck, but that heralds another problem where human resources do not give the best of their performance, leading to low productivity and waste of resources.
Minimizing the rate of such abuse is a matter that needs further research. We need to delve into the psychology of Emirati employees and understand the root of this cause as opposed to implement the traditional method of tightening sick leave rules. Investigation onto the employees’ morale and career goals could be a place to start when it comes to identifying how they wish to develop their careers for a mutual benefit. Going from rags to riches in 40 years, we have had a lot of adjustments to deal with at the speed of light. Perhaps this is why learning from other “Sick Leave Abuse” case studies may not apply, but I know one thing for sure, this is not a chronic trend and it can be changed with the right measures.
Sail eMagazine’s 18th Issue – September 2011
Here We Start – Art of Living 101 – Community Talk – Food for Thought
Just Another Undergrad – Society of Tomorrow – The First Years Last Forever
The Mind’s Eye – To the Point – Too Blunt for Words – Words, Observations, and Ramblings
A very interesting article and I am sure it will create a lot of debates. My two cents here would be, the law technically provides you with 15 days full-sick leave, and although Emirati has taken the majority of those sick leaves, an employee may think in terms of getting more paid vacation time. Or perhpas – despite healthcare system – they are really sick (and needed some days off). But some actually take sick leave to look for another job.
I once read an interesting article about, if you have a cold, or a flu, just take the day off. You are not going to productive – for the most part – and perhaps you could infect others. I personally would agree to a day off if you have gotten a cold. You are human after all. Does not mean you are lazy by any means. There are many reasons why possibly any person would take a day off, taking you child to the doctor, a cold, having severe menstrual pain for some women, aside from others.
And the issue with statistics, it only gives you numbers and not context all the time. For example, I would have like to know what was, lets say the top 3 reason an Emirati employee has taken a sick leave? Not having this answer makes you question the survey and if it was conducted in a comprehensive manner. I agree though, that the statistics point out to what you have discussed:
i.e.
– More Emiratis taking sick leave
– Younger than 35 accounted to 45%
But we don't know why these are the numbers, and like you said we need to delve into it. I would like to get in touch, if possible, with your colleague?
My experience, I have been working fo 4 months, and needed 1 day sick leave and once a half day. Why? Firstly, I had a cold and even people at work told me to go home. 2nd time, I had an important doctor appointment for an inury – which I delayed- for a long time, and just had to take half day off (and the dcotor was only available during weekdays, during normal work hours). So isn't taking almost 2 days off in a span of 4 months of a new job seems a bit questionable? If mentioned as such, then yes, but with the explanations, you get the aha, makes sense.
Anyways, good topic!
Hello Amna, Thanks for your extensive feedback. Where I used to work (private multinational firm) it was a policy that one or two days of sick leave did not require a doctors note. One, I actually find that efficient because not all sick people need a doctors for cases like flu or headache etc. Secondly, not having a doctors note, actually makes you take less of these sick leaves because then you wouldnt want ur boss thinking that you're taking advantage, so in one year, you end up taking less sick leave days. (i hope i explained that right)
Also, with regards to statistics, I should've probably mentioned that the main sick leave reasons pertain to diaorrhea, constipation, Flu! This survey was actually complied by the company itself (which my friend then used for her dissertation) so i trust the stats are correct, albeit will need further analysis.
There is no denying there is an evident misuse of the sick leave system, and personal expereinces along with that of my friends indicate a disturbing trend in young Emiratis. Laziness does prevail in many places and in this case, they most they will face in consequence is either get transfered to another department.
This was very interesting. We have the same problem in Kuwait. People skip school/college/work by taking sick leaves 'maratheeyas'. I honestly think the reason behind it is pure laziness.
Interesting article.
Nice to read criticism about emirati labor problems from emirati person. A good point here is given to the government who is working hard for the nationalisation of jobs. Although the effort is well recorded, the help and assistance from emirati youth is somehow contradicting: where some succeed and mostly more and more local employees fail to fulfill their job requirements.
I have once wrote abt the topic In Arabic
( hartakat.wordpress.com ) and I find it a debatable topic. We need to show the real situation without any exaggeration or subjectivity.
Finally, showing success stories from emratis youth and innovative persons is an introductory space to have a fruitful debate in this regard.
Salam Aleikom Kareem,
Thank you for your feedback. Yes this is a problem that needs addresing via more studies as it has been going on for a very long time. I will defintly read your article inshaAllah and I hope more people speak up as opposed to just gossiping about their colleagues for days to come.
I believe most don't take work seriously. They come from wealthy families and have the job to pass time
I know on the other hand great productive people such as the ones mentioned in the article and others who are successful in their jobs and recognized internationally
I think generalizing is not fair, however the careless percentage ruin it for the others
True, however many dont have to come from wealthy families as well. I've encountered many Emiratis who get emplyed in important positions and cant even draft a proper letter, mind you they graduated from universities in the UK and US! As you said, generalisation is not fair, but its safe to claim that both sides exist. Thanks for passing by.
Interesting that you stopped quoting the figures from the study just as you were getting to the gender ratios.
A very interesting article indeed, and I agree with Amna Al Haddad where a bit of more in depth analysis couldn’t have added 5 more stars to this article. Still amazingly written and thought about. Thank you!
Thank you Hassan. Word limit restricted further elaboration. Inshallah will look into another article with detailed approach now that I;ve introduced the general idea. Thanks
I like your article. It discusses a serious issue. Your are right that many people have the ideal the Emirates are lazy and not productive that why they prefer to hire other nationalities. Also, when Emirates get hired they will be given low level work. As to sick leave, it can not be denied that there are minor segment of locals who misuses the sick leave. Some people think that taking a sick leave will be better that being in a work whole day and not doing anything as their employers don’t care of them. I know some people who do this because of above reason. However, there are many examples of hard working and talented UAE nationals as you mentioned.
We do have similar problems with jobs in the Public Sector in Italy. Sometime the safety net of working in a bureaucratic environment pushes individuals to take advantage of the system. What is required is a stronger SME gov support ( that it's on it's way ). Keep in mind that some of the previously listed success stories would not have been possible without entrepreneurs having both a secured day job and the time to pursue their aspirations.
The creation if a quasi welfare state in the v govt v employment sector didn't help. simple universal fact it's of you know you can get b away with it you'll do it.
Even of it's done v worth the c right intentions. Forcing, organisations to create roles to fill quotas creates issues for both employee and employer. Competing on the c open market will cause short term, passion, but, long term, gain as education and workforce v wikl adapt.
Re the v study. Would be, good to see, more, stats. Reasons given, long and short term leave ratios. ratio of nationals in the company etc
Apologies. The above comment was written on my phone and a combination of predictive text and the fact you can't scroll down to see what you've typed resulted in the gibberish above…Fuller version below!
The creation of a quasi welfare state in the government employment sector doesn't help. It's a simple universal fact that if you know you can get away with it you'll do it. That applies all over the world.
Even if it's done with the right intentions. Forcing organisations to create roles for the sake of filling quotas creates issues for both employee and employer. I'd be willing to bet that if you audited all of the government jobs against the need for those jobs you'd be slashing employment in the govt sector by around 40%.
Competing on the open market will cause short term pain but long term gain as ambitions, expectations, the education system and people themselves will have to adapt to gain meaningful employment. As someone who employs people it always surprised me how ill equipped most people who went to school in the UAE (not just nationals) were to cope with the rigours of work.
The ethos of working your way to the top seems to have been lost (again not just nationals – I've come across many people in the UAE with a sense of entitlement because they have a degree). In other places in the world it is expected you will come in and do the menial job for a couple of years to learn how your profession works from the ground up. If you can't get a job doing what you want, you get a job doing what you need until you can find the right position. Again in a country with very high wealth levels I think there is an issue with unreasonably high expectations (same issue in Singapore for example) from the local workforce.
I agree that HR is a problem here. But its a problem for all nationalities. It's generally very below par and I don't think too many organisations here understand the role of HR – which in itself causes issues.
Re the study. I agree with Amna, It would be good to see more, stats. Reasons given for leave, long term vs short term leave ratiosm the ratio of nationals in the company (eg – if it was 60% staffed by nationals then 60% of sick leave would be a reasonable figure. If it was 5% of Nationals taking 60% of sick days then its an issue).
All in all, this is something that needs to be discussed in an intelligent way and as an expat I'm glad to see that this is starting to happen. Blaming an us vs them scenario is not helpful. The real issue – as always – is complex and multi-faceted.